Blog

There are a few situations where you can bring an appeal to a probate court decisions, but you must talk with a Dallas probate litigation attorney right away to find out how to do so effectively. Whether you went to court initially without a lawyer or you are displeased with the representation you had and want someone new for appeal, don’t hesitate to reach out to an experienced and proven probate attorney for the difficult process of an appeal.

From a Dallas Probate Litigation Attorney: Steps to an Appeal

Is the Decision Appealable?

The first step is discovering whether it’s possible for you to bring an appeal at all. Not all probate orders are appealable. For example, in the case In re Estate of Mims, the original order denying a motion to remove an executor wasn’t deemed final because of unadjudicated claims like attorney’s fees. Because the decision was not considered “final”, the appeals court rejected the appeal.

However, certain orders, like those admitting or denying a will, are immediately appealable under the Texas Estates Code. As you can tell, things can get quite complicated here, and that’s why it’s not only important to have a lawyer, but specifically one with extensive experience in probate law here in Texas.

Initiating the Appeal and Deadlines

Once you’ve determined that it’s likely you have grounds for an appeal, you need to file a notice of appeal with the original court that gave the decision you wish to appeal. This notice must be filed within 30 days from the date the judgment is signed, per Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 26.1. There are some exceptions to this 30-day rule, such as with a restricted appeal. If you meet the requirements for a restricted appeal, you can have up to six months to file.

There are some strict rules for a restricted appeal, however, and the notice of appeal that you file needs to stay clearly that you were affected by the initial judgment but did not participate in the hearing that resulted in that judgment. While a restricted appeal gives you more time, there is a downside in that the appellate court can only look at errors that are evident in the record. In other words, they are only allowed to look at the evidence that was presented initially. You may be asking the court to consider an appeal on more restricted information.

Ultimately, only a qualified lawyer can help you understand whether your circumstances might qualify for an exception to the 30-day rule. In some cases, the exceptions actually shorten the time limit, while in others, though they lengthen it, the accompanying restrictions can actually can make it harder for you to win. If you’re interested in an appeal, reach out to an attorney immediately. If you miss this deadline, in almost all cases you will lose the right to appeal at all.

Appeal Paperwork

Once the notice of appeal is filed, the next step is to prepare and file an appeal bond, or in some cases, a cash deposit or a statement of inability to afford payment of court costs. The bond amount will depend on the appellant’s (that’s you, if you are bringing the appeal) position in the original case.

After the bond is secured, the probate court clerk will prepare the record of the case to send on to the appeals court. This record will basically put together everything from the original trial, including all evidence, the documents that were submitted to the court, and any transcripts.

Appellant’s Brief

Next, your lawyer helps you to file the appellant’s brief. This document needs to make a clear and comprehensive legal argument for why you believe the original decision was legally incorrect. This brief has to follow a very specific format and contain specific items laid out in the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure. The legal arguments must be clearly articulated and supported by case law or statutes. You will always have a better chance of getting your appeal heard if you have an experienced lawyer preparing this document for you, because this is your chance to persuade the appellate court that the probate judge made a mistake that affected the outcome of the case.

The appellee (the party defending the probate court’s decision) then has the opportunity to file a response brief. This would normally counter the argument arguments that you are making and defend the original probate court’s decision.

The Fifth Court of Appeals

The appeal process in Dallas typically goes to the Fifth Court of Appeals, where the case will be reviewed for legal errors or abuses of discretion by the probate court. The “abuse of discretion” standard means that the appellate court can only overturn a decision if it believes that decision was made unreasonably or without reference to the evidence or the guiding principles of the court. In other words, there needs to have been a clear legal mistake by the probate judge for the appeals court to overturn it.

Given this standard, you must be able to pinpoint exactly what the legal errors were in the original proceedings and make a convincing case that these were indeed errors. The success rate of probate appeals under this standard is fairly low, as appellate courts tend to defer to the decisions made by the probate judges because probate judges are considered specialized experts in estate matters. Another area where you might be able to appeal would be by pointing out procedural errors in the original decision. For example, if the court or the other party did not follow the statutory requirements, such as by not giving you proper notice, you may be able to get the appeals court to overturn the decision.

In the end, the appeals court may affirm the probate court original decision, reverse it entirely, or send the case back to the probate court to continue based on the findings that the appellant court has made. Understand that this doesn’t necessarily mean you have “won.” In many cases, it just means that the probate court will have another chance to address the issues correctly. At this point, you very much want an experienced lawyer to help you go back to the original court and convince them to rethink the decision.

Appealing the Appeal

If the appellate court upholds the probate court’s decision, you still have the option to petition the Texas Supreme Court for review. However, you should be aware that this is a rare step and in most cases, a good lawyer will only recommend that you do this if they believe there are significant legal questions that have not been properly dealt with or conflicts in the way the law is interpreted between the different courts.

Always talk to your lawyer and listen with an open mind to their advice on whether it’s worth taking a case further. On top of that, bear in mind that the Texas Supreme Court has discretion over which cases to hear, and they generally only accept cases that could set important precedents or clarify conflicting interpretations of the law.

For experienced help in the probate courts or with an appeal, contact us at Ford + Bergner LLP in Dallas, Houston, or Austin today.