When a guardian fails in their duties, it’s the ward who suffers. Without proper care, medical needs may go unmet, causing them physical harm and emotional distress. Or, the ward’s finances may be mismanaged to the point where they face financial ruin. The Texas courts take these failures very seriously, and a guardianship lawyer in Houston can help you prove what’s going on and protect a vulnerable ward.
Signs of Guardian Failure
Be on the lookout for red flags that could indicate a guardian failing in their duties. Neglect can manifest as a ward not getting enough food or medicine or not living in a safe place. If the ward shows signs of emotionally withdrawing or of fear, there could be abuse involved. Financial mismanagement could show up in sold-off property, unpaid bills, or simply emptied bank accounts.
Oversight and Monitoring
Texas courts try to prevent mismanagement of a guardian through oversight. Guardians are required to submit annual reports about their ward’s condition and finances, and these reports are reviewed by court staff to catch early signs of trouble, like unexplained expenses or missed medical appointments. If a guardian fails to file these reports on time or submits incomplete information, the court may call them in for a hearing and demand an explanation.
In some cases, the court will appoint a monitor. This is especially common when there’s a high-risk situation, such as when a ward has such significant assets that there is a great temptation to steal or otherwise misuse. The court may appoint an attorney or a social worker to check on the ward’s well-being and the guardian’s actions on a regular basis. The monitor’s job is to immediately report neglect or mismanagement, or even the suspicion of it, to the court so an investigation can be triggered. This safety net is designed to catch problems before they escalate, but not every guardianship situation will have an appointed monitor right away. It’s important that family members and friends also keep up with monitoring the situation. If you notice a ward looking unwell or living in poor conditions, alert the court.
Unfortunately, even the best of oversight is not foolproof. Sometimes failures slip through and aren’t caught until the harm is already done. For this reason, there are strict and serious consequences for guardians who fail in their duties, particularly when that failure is purposeful.
Initial Consequences for the Guardian
If the court suspects that a guardian is mismanaging the situation, they will act quickly to protect the ward. The court will usually initiate an investigation to review the guardian’s actions on the condition of the ward. If the issue is fairly minor, such as reports being submitted late, the consequence may just be extra oversight and warnings. If the accusation is more serious, such as if there’s an accusation of theft or abuse, the court may immediately suspend the guardian temporarily. The court will then appoint someone to step in and fill the guardianship role while the investigation is ongoing. If the investigation turns up nothing, the guardian will likely be reinstated; but if not, there will be other penalties.
Removal of the Guardian
When a guardian’s actions are serious or ongoing, one of the first consequences is usually having their guardianship revoked entirely. This is a big step that is not taken lightly, not least of all because the guardian is often someone chosen by the family, and the court will not ignore the family’s wishes unless there’s a very good reason. However, if a guardian is constantly ignoring the orders of the court or has been stealing from the ward, they simply cannot continue in that position.
Removing a guardian starts with a hearing. At the hearing, evidence is presented and reviewed, and the guardian has a chance to defend themselves. If the court finds clear proof of failure, it will then appoint a new guardian to take over. There is often also a monitor appointed to help manage the transition carefully to avoid any unnecessary disruption to the life of the ward. In some cases, a temporary guardian steps in while a permanent replacement is found. Once a guardian has been removed, they will lose any fees that they were paid and will typically be barred from serving as guardian again.
Legal and Criminal Consequences
Sometimes, a guardian is removed simply because they’re not fit for the job. It’s not that they were trying to steal from the ward or deliberately did anything to mismanage the estate or failed to provide for the ward. They were just in over their heads, didn’t know how to make good decisions, or perhaps even just got lazy. In these cases, removal and reimbursement of fees may be the only consequences. But when a guardian goes further, there can be serious legal and criminal consequences. If a guardian abuses the ward physically or emotionally, they could face criminal charges like assault or elder abuse, especially if the ward is elderly or disabled. Financial misconduct, like embezzling the ward’s money, might lead to charges of theft or fraud.
When these kinds of charges are brought, there will be financial penalties and even prison time if the guardian is convicted. If the guardian has stolen from the ward’s estate, they will usually be ordered to repay the stolen amount plus interest and possibly extra damages. Beyond this, guardians can face a civil lawsuit from the ward, their family, or from a new guardian representing the ward. Any of these entities might sue for damages caused by neglect or mismanagement, and these lawsuits can cost the guardian quite a lot. It’s this threat of legal action that is often most effective at encouraging a guardian to act responsibly.
Protecting the Ward After Failure
If a ward has been harmed by the actions of a guardian, the court and the family can act to protect them. The court may, for example, order that the ward get immediate medical help. The court may seize the assets of the guardian to repay the ward or allow the state to tap into the bond, if there is one. A bond is a type of insurance that guardians are often required to buy, which is designed to cover just such situations.
Despite the best intentions of family and court, a guardian’s failure can have lasting effects on a ward: physical, emotional, and financial. For this reason, it’s very important to do everything possible to prevent guardianship issues before they start. The courts already have some of these prevention measures in place: before someone can be appointed as a guardian, the courts will check their background for financial issues or a criminal history, and guardians must take training on all their duties and report regularly to the court. The courts also often require guardians to post a bond to cover the losses if funds are mismanaged.
But it’s also key that the family be very cautious in appointing a guardian and act quickly if there’s any suspicion that a guardian is not taking their duties seriously and acting in the best interest of the ward.
Talk to a Guardianship Lawyer in Houston
If you have any suspicions about a guardian, or if you need help and advice on choosing the right guardian for your loved one,
contact Ford + Bergner LLP in Houston for help. We also serve the Dallas and Austin areas.